Whoever Listens to a Female Singer, And ,Music Makes Hypocrisy Grow

Question :

I read in a Hadith that the Prophet said, "Whoever listens to a female singer, then molten lead will be poured into his ears." And another Hadith: "Music makes hypocrisy grow in the heart just as water makes grass grow." Are these Hadiths authentic? And what is the ruling regarding someone who hears singing in a car or in a gathering, when he does not have the ability to turn it off?

Answer:

Listening to a voice implies that one is listening carefully, concentrating on what he is listening to. So in the case of singing, listening to it implies that one is listening carefully and concentrating on it.

As for hearing, it could be on purpose, the same as listening. carefully and concentrating, in which case it is also called. listening, and the same judgements apply. On the other hand, hearing could occur without it happening on purpose, without concentrating on the voice, then it is not called listening and the judgements related to listening do not apply.

Accordingly, listening to what the questioner mentioned, different types of singing, is unlawful for anyone who concentrates on it. This is the case, be it a man, a woman, in the home, or not in the home, in the car, or in gatherings, large or small. It is the same, whenever one chooses to do so, and is inclined to participate in what is unlawful according to the Shari'ah.

Allah Almighty said:
"And of mankind is he who purchases idle talk (Lahwul-Hadith) to mislead men from the path of Allah without knowledge, and takes it by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment."

The singing that the questioner mentioned is part of Lahwul- Hadith. It tempts heart, and it leads it to evil, taking it away from good, and causing people to waste their time. So because of this it falls under the general meaning of Lahwul-Hadith, it is the same for one singing and the one who listens to singing, all of them fall under the general category of purchasing Lahwul- Hadith and misleading others from the path of Allah. So there is prohibition and a warning of a sever punishment for doing so.

Just as the prohibition of singing and listening to it is proven in the Qur'an, so too has the Sunnah. The Prophet ﷺ said :
"There will be from my Nation a people who will deem fornication, silk (for men), alcohol, and music to be permissible; and there will be a people who will camp beside a high mountain, when a poor man passes by them and asks for a need, they will say to him, "Return to us tomorrow. In the morning Allah will make the mountain fall upon them and the others (who saved) are are transformed into apes and pigs, until the Day of Judgement.

Music is the use of instruments of Lahw, and part of this is singing and listening to it. So Allah's Messenger condemned those who seek to legalize fornication, the use of silk for men, drinking alcohol, and such entertainment instruments and listening to them. Here he accompanied music with other major sins. In the end of the Hadith he threatened those who do that. with a punishment.

This shows that listening to music is unlawful. But a person is not sinning when he accidentally listens to music, such as a person who is walking in the street and hears music being played in stores, or in a car, as long as he does not desire to listen to it. Such a person is not sinning because he has no choice; however, he must advise and warn those who are playing the music, and he must do so with wisdom and good exhortation. And he should avoid as much as possible going to places where music is played, and Allâh does not place a burden on a soul greater than it can bear.

A group of scholars use authentic proofs and then follow that with narrations that have some weakness in their chains of narration, or from the view of proving the objective. There is nothing wrong in this because they mention these narrations as secondary, narrations to be reflected upon, but they depend entirely on authentic Hadiths for proof. An example of this is regarding singing and listening to it, where scholars first mention the authentic narrations and then mention narrations that are weak. Here are some examples of the weak narrations:

1) Al-Hakim At-Tirmithi related from Abu Musa Al-'Ashari that the Prophet ﷺ said:
"Whoever listens to the sound of singing will not be permitted to listen to the spirits in Paradise."

2) Ibn 'Asakir relates from Anas, may Allah be pleased with him, that the Prophet ﷺ said :
"Whoever listens to a female singer, molten lead will be poured into his ears on the Day of Judgement."

3) In Thamm Al-Malahi Ibn Abi Ad-Dunya' relates from Ibn Mas'ud a saying of the Prophet ﷺ :
"Singing makes hypocrisy to grow in the heart like water makes herbs grow."

4) Al-Bayhaqi related from Jabir, may Allâh be pleased with him, that the Prophet ﷺ said :
"Singing makes hypocrisy to grow in the heart like water makes plants grow."

All of these Hadiths are weak, but just because they are weak doesn't affect the ruling on singing and on listening to singing: both are unlawful because of other authentic proofs from the Qur'an and the Sunnah. And with Allah is the facilitation to do what is right.