If the Imam deputizes a Latecomer Who has missed Two Rak'ahs to take His Place
Question :
If the Imam lost his Wudhu' due to breaking wind in the fourth Rak'ah of the prayer, and appointed in his place as Imam one who arrived late, catching the prayer in the third Rak'ah, what is the ruling on those who began the prayer in the first Rak'ah or the second with the first Imam? Is it allowed for them to make the Taslim before the second Imam, or is it permissible to add to the length of the prayer by following the second Imam?
Answer:
If the situation of the worshippers is as described, it is obligatory for those who caught the first and second Rak'ahs with the first Imam not to stand with the second Imam when he stands up to complete his prayer; instead, they should remain sitting, because they have already prayed four Rak'ahs and that is the obligatory prayer. And it is not permissible for them to make the Taslim before the Imam, because it has been authentically reported from the Prophet that he said:
The Imam is there to be followed...
And may peace and blessings be upon our Prophet, Muhammad and upon his family and Companions.
Source:
The Permanent Committee
Fatawa Islamiyah, Vol. 2 Pages 175-176
أرسلها على تطبيق الواتساب 